All reports
Caylus reports
#15252: "Construction track with fatal error"
What is this report about?
What happened? Please select from below
Rules: a rule of the game has not been followed
Detailed description
• Which part of the rules was not followed by the BGA adaptation?
The rules say that when you collect favor on the construction track line, first you move the marker to the right (if possible) and second, you can choose a building of any type, as far as the marker goes.
Las reglas dicen que al cobrar favor en fila de track de construcción Primero se avanza marcador a la derecha (de ser posible) y Segundo, se puede escoger edificio de cualquier tipo, hasta donde llegue marcador• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
Final round. I made the normal move to move to Stone Building, and then couldn't choose Wood Building. The fully flawed implementation of BGA forces you to choose wanted building and the software then advances the score. It is not only inconvenient but illegal
Ronda final. Hice el movimiento normal de avanzar a Edificio de piedra y luego no pude escoger edificio de madera. La implementación errada totalmente de BGA obliga a elegir edificio querido y el software luego avanza el marcador. No sólo es inconveniente sino ilegal• Which browser are you using?
Google Chrome v80
Report history
Apr 5th 2020 14:44 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
I have played more than 30 games in real life and some here. The way to implement this track is horrifying. The normal thing to do in real life is, First, move the marker on the construction track and Second, choose which building to build. Here it is the other way around. First the building to be built and then the marker goes ahead. Totally non-intuitive. It is a total and absolute bug. It has made me lose games, forgetting the bug, in the final round.
Apr 5th 2020 14:49 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
I have seen many complaints about this bug and the developers have never bothered to reply, due to which they are closed. I am a paid subscriber and I demand adequate attention and a prompt solution to this problem
He visto muchas quejas sobre este bug y jamás los desarrolladores se han tomado la molestia de contestar, debido a lo cual se cierran. Soy suscriptor pagado y exijo una atención adecuada y una solución pronta a este problema
He visto muchas quejas sobre este bug y jamás los desarrolladores se han tomado la molestia de contestar, debido a lo cual se cierran. Soy suscriptor pagado y exijo una atención adecuada y una solución pronta a este problema
Apr 5th 2020 14:56 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
Move 299 It is where the illegality of your algorithm occurred. I chose to move track building. Marker advance to stone building space (legal advance) and then I chose previous stone building (legal movement). Your algorithm illegally estimated that when advancing to stone my only option was to build a stone building. That presumption is totally contrary to the Caylus rules.
Movimiento 299 es donde ocurrió la ilegalidad de vuestro algoritmo. Elegí avanzar track edificio. Avance marcador a casilla de edificio de piedra (avance legal) y luego escogí edificio de piedra previo (movimiento legal). Vuestro algoritmo ilegalmente estimó que al avanzar a piedra mi única opción era construí edificio de piedra. Esa presunción es totalmente contraria a las reglas de Caylus.
Movimiento 299 es donde ocurrió la ilegalidad de vuestro algoritmo. Elegí avanzar track edificio. Avance marcador a casilla de edificio de piedra (avance legal) y luego escogí edificio de piedra previo (movimiento legal). Vuestro algoritmo ilegalmente estimó que al avanzar a piedra mi única opción era construí edificio de piedra. Esa presunción es totalmente contraria a las reglas de Caylus.
Apr 5th 2020 15:35 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
Serious error is a trap in which boardgamearena users must necessarily fall into a couple of games, before understanding the twisted logic of the system
El error grave es una trampa en la cual los usuarios de boardgamearena necesariamente deben caer en un par de partidas, antes de entender la retorcida lógica del sistema
El error grave es una trampa en la cual los usuarios de boardgamearena necesariamente deben caer en un par de partidas, antes de entender la retorcida lógica del sistema
Apr 6th 2020 14:27 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
Apr 10th 2020 13:40 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
Esperando y activando este foro para que no muera
May 9th 2020 15:56 • anmi2 • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
ebenso /bug?id=3553
dort bereits kommentiert plus beispiel
dort bereits kommentiert plus beispiel
Jun 14th 2020 14:47 • Wuuuschel • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
habe das Problem schon unter bug ID 3553 angegeben.
Hoffe Ihr könnte das ändern, vielen Dank!
Hoffe Ihr könnte das ändern, vielen Dank!
Nov 5th 2021 0:26 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
Sigue el problema
Problem persists
Problem persists
Aug 27th 2022 6:17 • Uncle Milo • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
Table #281621830
I bought a favor and selected to build a wooden building and it simply moved on to the next player. It took my coin and my cloth and did not let me actually make the wooden building.
Please help!
I bought a favor and selected to build a wooden building and it simply moved on to the next player. It took my coin and my cloth and did not let me actually make the wooden building.
Please help!
Sep 25th 2024 15:18 • marioaguila • Bug has not been reproduced by developers yet:
The error keeps happening. Since the game is already in progress, I’ve decided to stop playing it. It doesn’t even let me undo my move.
Add to this report
Please add here anything that seems relevant in order to reproduce this bug or understand your suggestion:
- Another table ID / move ID
- Did F5 solve the problem?
- Did the problem appear several times? Every time? Randomly?
- If you have a screenshot of this bug (good practice), you can use Imgur.com to upload it and copy/paste the link here.
